• Create an account
    *
    *
    *
    *
    *
    *
    Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

ACTIVE VS PASSIVE "LEADERSHIP


"In a world full of horse trainers, clinicians and equine professionals competing to make a mark for themselves, many find new ways to reinvent the wheel; however, several try to put their knowledge into some package where we may identify with it all. In the equine world, leadership is the key to survival and many of these professionals communicate their opinion of equine behavior and how we should cope with this dynamic. The question now becomes, what form of leadership is right for us?

In the human world, some people define leadership simply as getting people to work to achieve common goals and giving people a reason (motivation) to work (active leadership). Other people hold that leadership is the ability to influence the behavior of others, to set up goals, to formulate paths to those goals, and to create and guide toward good behavior (passive leadership). Isn’t that what we want to accomplish in the equine world - to influence and motivate safe behaviors? Many leaders have always wondered how active or passive they should be. The active leader risks exacerbating the problem by tackling it; the passive leader risks being overwhelmed by a problem that festers unchecked. Peace, order, and good government are noble aspirations, but they should not dictate passivity in a treacherous world. Sometimes, the only way to achieve peace, order, and any kind of reasonable government is to be proactive, even aggressive, as demonstrated by the many wars that have been fought.

Now to answer the question of “which leadership is right for equine training”? Mark Rashid, a well-respected clinician, presents very simply and nicely his definition of “Passive Leadership” in this way:

“There are two types of leaders in a herd situation. The alpha, or lead horse, that rules by dominance, and passive leaders that lead by example. The passive leaders are usually chosen by other members of the herd and are followed willingly, while alphas use force to declare their place in the herd. Passive leaders are usually older horses somewhere in the middle of the herd's pecking order. They are quiet and consistent in their day-to-day behavior and don't appear to have much ambition to move up the "alpha" ladder. As a result, there appears to be no reason for them to use force to continually declare their position in the herd. Alphas, on the other hand, are usually pretty far from being quiet and consistent in their behavior. They are often very pushy, sometimes going as far as using unprovoked attacks on subordinates for the simple reason of declaring their dominance. As a result of this behavior, the majority of the horses in the herd will actually avoid all contact with the alpha throughout the day.”

  Rashid article entitled “Passive Leadership” Challenging the Alpha Theory.

 What Mr. Rashid is trying to convey is- that it does not need to be an all out war of aggression and wills to get a horse to comply with an unwanted behavior. Leadership was broken down into two forms- active and passive. If a horse decides to push, bite, squeal, or kick out at you, how would you set the example to teach it that was not appropriate behavior? I am sure your behavior was exemplary and did not kick it or push it out of the way first, so how does setting an example fix that behavior? Mr. Rashid would rather out think the horse and go with the flow than against it. One of the tenets of “Natural Horsemanship” is - “be soft as possible and firm as necessary.” Nowhere does it say “be firm unless the horse is the alpha and he should have his way” then walk away. The alpha horse expects that you or other horses will be subordinate to him. Even the passive leader is in the middle of the order. When you are leading a horse or on a trail ride and the horse bolts, kicks out or rears up, do you want to be the subordinate and just do what the horse wants? Who is the more frail species? Who is more likely to get hurt? Do you see the danger in being a passive leader in this situation?

Here is the danger in passive leadership and the importance of this article - There are many types of personalities in both humans and horses. Many horses have very strong outgoing personalities (extroverted) and would rather challenge, while others just go with the flow (introverted). None of us want to pick a fight with a sumo wrestler, just as we would not want to challenge an ill-tempered horse. If a person owns a horse that has a strong, willful personality, passive leadership would not suit well with this situation. On the other hand, active leadership could affectively motivate and influence both a willful horse and a mild-mannered horse. The passive leader will do well only if the passive horse is more passive or submissive than the leader. There is still a pecking order, regardless of whether you are a passive leader or not, and the passive leader will never be an all-encompassing, true leader because he is not at the top of the order. Balance - Horses do not constantly battle each other to establish dominance…the subordinate horse acknowledges the leader’s role and will come back another day to try his luck. Similarly, they will ”alpha check” you to make sure you are still the leader from one week to the next. It comes down to survival for the horse. At the opportune time, when we assert our leadership and get the desired response (active), we then step back from the line and simply lead with the full knowledge that we are in our rightful position as leader (passive); this displays confidence and consistency in our leadership to the horse.

Marketing - Because of the demographics in the horse industry where women and recreational riders make up more than 80% of equine activities, it is no wonder why the idea of passive leadership is so popular in some circles. It is easier to market the idealism of “let’s not scold the horse, let’s be touchy-feely and lead by example” attitude. Many new and inexperienced recreational riders are disillusioned of the true nature of the horse and think that “assertiveness” is a bad word meaning the use of forceful persuasion through violence toward the horse. When we go for a trail ride, we are always admonished to be an active rider not a reactive or passive rider.

The reason for this active position is so that we are always prepared to take the lead to control or correct issues that need attention if the horse displays an unwanted behavior. When you go to buy a horse, do you know if the horse has a more passive attitude than you? Many people get hurt or die each year because they did not take a more an active role in leadership with their horse. Whether you see yourself as an active leader or as a passive leader, you had better be the horse’s leader. Simply put, leadership is established by moving and controlling the feet or body in six directions and at three major gaits. The degree of leadership is in the degree of your ability to control the horse through active or passive leadership.

The key to this leadership issue is a “sound balance” to your approach and understanding through education in sound principals. God did not give horses dominion over humans, but gave horses to us, as their stewards, as a gift.


 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Articles

Written on 11/01/2016, 12:26 by admin
modern-vs-classical-dressage-is-there-a-differenceModern vs Classical Dressage, is there a difference? You Have you ever heard of an instructor say "I only teach classical principles" or "classical dressage"? After all, isn't Western Dressege built on classical principles? I can't recall anyone bragging about teaching competitive or modern...
Written on 23/04/2015, 11:23 by admin
genghis-khan-in-the-art-of-riding-correctlySomehow I don’t think Genghis Khan of the Mongol Empire (1162-1227 AD) rode "two handed” in a curb bit while cutting off the the heads of his enemies on horse back.  For years I have felt that my rants have fallen on death ears. I am glad that I am not the only person that feels...
Written on 23/02/2015, 13:06 by admin
light-handsWhat does the term "Light Hands” or "Soft Feel" mean to you in regards to Western Dressage? What can we learn from great leaderships like Ronald Reagan, Teddy Roosevelt, and Dwight Eisenhower? The USA won the cold war in part because President Reagan was willing to back up his words with unyielding...
Written on 11/02/2015, 09:08 by admin
new-article Where has common sense gone these days? Have you ever seen something that made you shake your head in disbelief? This reminds me of a phrase I have heard: “If you tell a lie long enough, it becomes the truth.”  “Wisdom is not just the use of knowledge, to properly use wisdom you...
Written on 11/05/2014, 09:01 by admin
seeking-truth-one-hand-at-a-time “The greatest enemy of knowledge is "NOT" ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge.”  ― Daniel J. Boorstin, The Discoverers: A History of Man's Search to Know His World and Himself What does the above statement mean to you? What is the best way to gain power and infuence over folks? The...
Written on 20/03/2013, 18:25 by admin
what-does-true-collection-look-like Randy, "How do I know that I am doing Western Dressage correctly?" That is a great question, I am glad you asked. I get this question quite often. It would be helpful if the water was not so muddy, right? To help answer this question I have a few questions for you as well. "Are you a truth seeker...
Written on 10/03/2013, 13:49 by admin
proper-use-of-holding-a-bridle-horseRiding out on the trail or schooling, riders often hold their reins in whatever way is most comfortable or useful. Riding casually, we might use two hands, or cross the reins, or switch frequently from hand to hand, but in the horse show ring, rules are very specific about how the reins are held, and...
Written on 01/01/2013, 21:31 by admin
the-what-is-the-difference-the-five-ws-of-western-dressageThe “What is the Difference?” "The Five W's of Western Dressage": “What? Why? Who? Where? When?” Do you need an excuse to be with your horse? If you are like me, probably not. Even mucking Carbon's stall is enjoyable; I love every minute I spend with my boy. Have you ever gotten on your horse and...
Written on 28/12/2012, 23:58 by admin
demystifying-the-pyramid-what-is-the-training-scaleDemystifying The Pyramid "Training Scale?" Do you remember sitting in high school and not understanding the question that everyone else seemed to know the answer to?  Do you remember being so afraid to raise your hand that you pretended you already knew the answer and regretted it when the...
144710
Written on 15/12/2012, 21:31 by admin
the-five-ws-of-western-dressageThe “Why?” "The Five W's of Western Dressage": “What? Why? Who? Where? When?” In the last year, there have been lots of people asking, “What is Western Dressage?” You may have seen an article or two labeled, “What is Western Dressage?” Simply put, Western Dressage is a method of training that brings...
Written on 15/10/2012, 18:00 by admin
snaffle-vs-curbI have a question, Randy: If a horse goes nicely in a snaffle, why do you need to change to a curb or (bridle)? Good question, here is the answer: "Very few folks can ride bridlelss, but even fewer can ride with a bridle!" ~ Eitan Beth-Halachmy The simple truth is that you do not need a...
1633490
Written on 14/10/2012, 16:37 by admin
what-did-your-horse-teach-you-today  Question: I have a beautiful 9 year old Paint/Qtr gelding. He hadn't been handled in over a year before we brought him home, but we've been handling him everyday. However, most of the handling has been allowing him to graze on the lead. Last weekend, I attempted to give him some wormer...
219140
Written on 29/09/2012, 15:08 by admin
the-use-of-the-curb-bit-a-lower-levels Bethe Mounce Question---"why the curb chain and not a plain snaffle? This is lower level dressage, right?"This question is in reference to riding Western Dressage tests in a curb bit or snaffle bit. I am not sure if I fully understand the question, but  you mention a curb chain… I think...
Written on 29/09/2012, 15:03 by admin
why-use-a-cavasenRandy I have a question, "why do you use a Cavesson?"thanks Brock HolbrookThat is a great question and here is my answer: Analogy:Think of using a cavesson like you would if you went to the orthodontist to get braces put on your teeth. It is a temporary tool to fix a problem. Once the problem is...
311120
Written on 22/06/2012, 22:40 by admin
randy-byers-truth-revealed"Rearing and flipping over backwards is the single most dangerous thing a horse can do!"Why does a horse rear?Rearing is a refusal to go forward or an evasion to your "go forward" aids or cues!""How do you fix a rearing problem? Simply put, "keep the horse's feet moving in any direction except...
129870
Written on 11/04/2012, 12:29 by admin
what-is-a-bridle-horseDeveloping a good "Western Dressage Bridle Horse" is all about your expectations of what you want in a "finished horse". There are many training methods claiming that they are the only correct way to train a horse. Even though there are many ways to "start", "develop", or "finish" a horse, the...
156930
Written on 04/04/2012, 16:44 by admin
q-a-flying-lead-change"Transitioning from a Simple Change to a Flying Change"   "I am going to be showing this summer, but I have been working for a few months on lead changes and my horse can get where he does like half a trot stride then goes to the next lead, but I can't get him to do an actual flying...
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:13 by admin
ground-manners  "My name is Briana. I’m training a 2-year old mare and she does not know her ground manners. What do I do and how do I teach her good ground manners?"   Thank you for asking these questions. This is a very widely researched topic. There are many books, videos, DVDs and other educational...
101010
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:12 by admin
how-do-i-get-her-to-slow-down  "How do I get her to slow down, collect, and accept the bit and stop being so neurotic about whenever the reins are gathered and the bit makes contact with her mouth?"   This is a great question and you have given me lots of detail to help in forming a response. I like to define a...
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:11 by admin
speed-control  I like to define a ‘broke horse’ by saying that you have full control of direction and impulsion, regardless of how good your ground work is and how soft he is. Using this definition, If you cannot control the speed of the canter, he is not broke or not broke enough. The quick and simple...
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:10 by admin
anthropomorphism “My horse sleeps better at night in a barn because he feels safe, my horse comes to me in the field because he loves me, my horse won't take its medicine just to spite me.” We can’t help but love our equine friends because of their social nature, but can we be accused of the dangerous behavior of...
317570
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:05 by admin
i-can-t-control-my-horse-on-the-ground  Question: I have a beautiful 9 year old Paint/Qtr gelding. He hadn't been handled in over a year before we brought him home, but we've been handling him everyday. However, most of the handling has been allowing him to graze on the lead. Last weekend, I attempted to give him some wormer...
303790
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:01 by admin
active-vs-passive-leadership "In a world full of horse trainers, clinicians and equine professionals competing to make a mark for themselves, many find new ways to reinvent the wheel; however, several try to put their knowledge into some package where we may identify with it all. In the equine world, leadership is the key to...
193250
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:00 by admin
natural-horsemanship-what-is-its-message In the world of “Natural Horsemanship”, there is a widely used phrase “be as soft as possible and as firm as necessary.” It you ask 20 people what Natural Horsemanship means, you will get 20 different answers. There is also a growing concern about how firm is too firm and how gentle is too gentle. If...
103080
Written on 26/03/2012, 00:58 by admin
confidence-is-leadership-in-action-and-fear "I have been raising a family for the last 20 years and I need help with my confidence. I was a fearless rider when I was younger, but now I am nervous. Last year I got hurt and I am not sure if I want to just hop on, now. My horse is very pushy on the ground when I lead him." “Confidence” is...
You are here: Home Home Articles Articles ACTIVE VS PASSIVE "LEADERSHIP