• Create an account
    *
    *
    *
    *
    *
    *
    Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Modern vs Classical Dressage, is there a difference?

Modern vs Classical Dressage, is there a difference?

imageYou Have you ever heard of an instructor say "I only teach classical principles" or "classical dressage"? After all, isn't Western Dressege built on classical principles? I can't recall anyone bragging about teaching competitive or modern dressage, have you? 

First, I would like to clarify the use of the word Dressage; it can be used as a verb, adjective or a noun. In this article I am using it as a proper NOUN.

There is no shortage of opinions or useless information (including my opinion) on this issue. Why is articulating the difference between the two concepts important or of any concern to you? If the two concepts are different, should you be aware of the difference so you can convey that knowledge to your horse properly? There are many counterfeit trainers and instructors that claim one thing, but do just the opposite. This is call hypocrisy. Do you want to know how to spot a counterfeit Dressage instructor?   

Over the years I have been critical regarding folks making the claim they teach pure classical dressage, but yet they can't seem to articulate the difference in the two. Lets stop being emotional and analyze this topic to get to the truth. 

Both concepts argue or claim:
  • Lightness to the aids as a goal
  • Suppleness as a goal
  • Better balance
  • Forward moving
  • Self carriage
  • Harmony as a goal
  • Willingness as a goal
  • Partnership as a goal
  • Use of gymnastic exercises
  • Welfare of the horse as a goal
  • Art form as a goal
  • Straightness as a goal
  • Obedience as a goal
  • Impulsion as a goal
  • Collection as a goal
  • Up hill as a goal
Did I leave anything out? Who cares, do you see my point? Both concepts claim the same concepts are being adhere too, but are there still two differences in the two? Yes there is! What are they?

#1 Modern dressage came out of the ashes of classical that uses verifiable testing to validate proper method of training. Whereas classical has no verifiable validation of proper training. In other words you can say you are an awesome classical instructor, but there is no way to validate your claim. 

#2 Classical dressage was a method of training war and field working horses back in earlier centuries. It was mandatory to train a horse with a method that allows the rider to ride one handed while using the other hand as an utility. Other than freestyle, modern dressage does not allow one handed testing. Why is this important to know? Because many folks seem to think all you need to do is drop the right rein and ride one handed. That cannot be further from the truth. It requires you to re-school your horse with a different feel and use of aids. The training method to train a horse to the goal of riding one handed is not the same method of teaching a horse to be ridden sole with two hands. It would be like using tuna fish to make hamburgers, they are not compatible.  This is why I like Working Equitation, it is a verifiable test to validate whether a working horse has been trained properly in classical principles. Truth is self evident and needs very little explaintion. It is easy to spot a counterfeit, just watch any instructor ride his/her demo horse and the truth will be demonstrated by the horse. Oh if the instructor does not have a demo horse, run away like hell and never look back. 

This article was inspired by the following information from Lusitano portal. 

10636065 695695090521245 8628854623523544616 n
http://lusitanoportal.com/classical-dressage/

The tradition of educating and training horses to perform movements goes far back into history. In ancient days the main purpose for most horses was to function on the battlefield. It was later, during the Renaissance, that the nature of riding changed. To ride and educate a horse became the noble hobby of kings and aristocrats. This gave rise to the grand riding academies where dancing with a horse became a goal in itself and riding developed into an art form.

classical-dressage-300x172 What is Classical Dressage?

The term ’Classical Dressage’ can be interpreted in many ways and today there are plenty of different schools. The view that we present here aims to be open and not state what is right or wrong – many roads may lead to Rome but in dressage, and riding in general, we often have to deal with multiple versions of Rome itself! A quote from General Alexis L’Hotte (1825-1904), an early chief trainer at Cadre Noir in Saumur, beautifully captures what Classical Dressage and Equestrian Art is about:

“The beauties of the horse reside in the nobleness, the grace, the boldness of his movements, their splendid achievement, their energy. The beautiful horsemanship, in its delicacy and its good taste, seeks the development of these gifts belonging to the horse, and not in perverting them. It is nature which we take as a guide, and not the extraordinary, the eccentric which we seek.”

Light and graceful horses

Classical Dressage, Classical Horsemanship and Equestrian Art all involve training and handling of horses in accordance with ancient and well proven methods. with the main aim that the horse ridden should move and execute exercises with the same lightness and as gracefully as he does when free. The various dressage exercises are not goals in themselves, rather they are seen as a means of achieving a healthy, strong, supple and well balanced horse that can express his natural movements and dance under a rider without tension or friction. This is accomplished through a trustful relationship in everyday training, which itself is based on gymnastic and strengthening exercises where one exercise logically leads to another.

capriole-300x225 CAPRIOLE PERFORMED BY RIDER AND HORSE FROM THE PORTUGUESE SCHOOL OF EQUESTRIAN ART

School jumps were probably not used for attack

Classical Dressage is not so much about school jumps and high school exercises as it is about developing a supple and well balanced horse. It is important to remember that in earlier centuries horses were mostly owned and used by the military and that these horses not only had to be obedient and maneuverable, but also needed to stay sound for many years. It is widely believed that the military trained their horses to perform the airs above the ground as maneuvers to use for either attack or evade of the enemy. For example, the levad could have allowed the rider to see better, or the capriole used as a leap to escape when surrounded. That the school jumps were ever used in battle is however doubtful, as most of them expose the horse’s sensitive underbelly. It is instead more likely that these exercises were used to further develop the horse and rider and to demonstrate the control and strength of the horse.

by-johann-georg-hamilton-300x253

PAINTING BY JOHANN GEORG HAMILTON

The difference between Classical and Competitive dressage

What we know today as classical riding has evolved from ancient cavalry training, while competitive dressage displayed in the present day has in turn evolved out of these classical principles. Competitive dressage displays all the movements used at the grand riding academies with the exception of the airs above the ground. In actual fact, it is not absolutely necessary to differentiate the two as, at least in theory, competitive dressage should follow the same principles – the FEI dressage judging criteria, for example, expresses an emphasis on harmony and lightness. There does not have to be any contradiction between classical training and competing. But in what is called classical dressage, the goal in performing certain exercises is not to get a score from a judge, but to strengthen the horse, to make him able to carry a rider without shortening his “working life” rather to prolong it.. The classical approach also involves the idea that all horses can perform all exercises. , and they can, but perhaps not always to the standard expected of the dressage course.

Classical Dressage according to famous riders

Just as L’Hotte put it in the quotation above, many famous riders and masters express that Classical Dressage is about the natural beauty of the horse and a harmonious relationship between horse and rider. Contemporary Mestre Luís Valença has also spoken on the subject, expressing that equestrian art is about three things: Firstly the love, beauty, kindness and elegance of the horse’s movements. Secondly that the horse is allowed to express his style and personality with his spirit unbroken. Finally, that the rider must base his relationship with the horse on love to be able to get the best out of the horse.

The following quotes from other masters and famous riders express what classical horsemanship means to them:

“Equitation or the Art of Riding means to cultivate the movement of the horse with as little effort as possible”
– Egon von Neindorff

“Equestrian art is the perfect understanding and harmony between horse and rider”
– Nuno Oliviera

“The objective of the Classical Art of Riding is to train the horse not only to be brilliant in the movements and the exercises of the High School but also to be quiet, supple and obedient and by his smooth movements to make riding a true pleasure”
– Alois Podhajsky

“It is the ability, by means of good exercises, logically structured and based on the natural laws of balance and harmony, to train the horse so that it subordinates itself to the rider´s will contentedly and with self-confidence, without any detriment whatsoever to its own natural sequence of movement.”
– Anja Beran

Sources: Alexis-Francois L’Hotte: The Quest for Lightness in Equitation by H, Nelson; The Art of Classical Horsemanship by E Neindorff; Dressage: The Art of Classical Riding by S, Loch; Classical Dressage in Competition by Dr. T, Ritter; artisticdressage.com; valencaequestriantours.com; classical-equitation.com


Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Articles

Written on 11/01/2016, 12:26 by admin
modern-vs-classical-dressage-is-there-a-differenceModern vs Classical Dressage, is there a difference? You Have you ever heard of an instructor say "I only teach classical principles" or "classical dressage"? After all, isn't Western Dressege built on classical principles? I can't recall anyone bragging about teaching competitive or modern...
Written on 23/04/2015, 11:23 by admin
genghis-khan-in-the-art-of-riding-correctlySomehow I don’t think Genghis Khan of the Mongol Empire (1162-1227 AD) rode "two handed” in a curb bit while cutting off the the heads of his enemies on horse back.  For years I have felt that my rants have fallen on death ears. I am glad that I am not the only person that feels...
Written on 23/02/2015, 13:06 by admin
light-handsWhat does the term "Light Hands” or "Soft Feel" mean to you in regards to Western Dressage? What can we learn from great leaderships like Ronald Reagan, Teddy Roosevelt, and Dwight Eisenhower? The USA won the cold war in part because President Reagan was willing to back up his words with unyielding...
Written on 11/02/2015, 09:08 by admin
new-article Where has common sense gone these days? Have you ever seen something that made you shake your head in disbelief? This reminds me of a phrase I have heard: “If you tell a lie long enough, it becomes the truth.”  “Wisdom is not just the use of knowledge, to properly use wisdom you...
Written on 11/05/2014, 09:01 by admin
seeking-truth-one-hand-at-a-time “The greatest enemy of knowledge is "NOT" ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge.”  ― Daniel J. Boorstin, The Discoverers: A History of Man's Search to Know His World and Himself What does the above statement mean to you? What is the best way to gain power and infuence over folks? The...
Written on 20/03/2013, 18:25 by admin
what-does-true-collection-look-like Randy, "How do I know that I am doing Western Dressage correctly?" That is a great question, I am glad you asked. I get this question quite often. It would be helpful if the water was not so muddy, right? To help answer this question I have a few questions for you as well. "Are you a truth seeker...
Written on 10/03/2013, 13:49 by admin
proper-use-of-holding-a-bridle-horseRiding out on the trail or schooling, riders often hold their reins in whatever way is most comfortable or useful. Riding casually, we might use two hands, or cross the reins, or switch frequently from hand to hand, but in the horse show ring, rules are very specific about how the reins are held, and...
Written on 01/01/2013, 21:31 by admin
the-what-is-the-difference-the-five-ws-of-western-dressageThe “What is the Difference?” "The Five W's of Western Dressage": “What? Why? Who? Where? When?” Do you need an excuse to be with your horse? If you are like me, probably not. Even mucking Carbon's stall is enjoyable; I love every minute I spend with my boy. Have you ever gotten on your horse and...
Written on 28/12/2012, 23:58 by admin
demystifying-the-pyramid-what-is-the-training-scaleDemystifying The Pyramid "Training Scale?" Do you remember sitting in high school and not understanding the question that everyone else seemed to know the answer to?  Do you remember being so afraid to raise your hand that you pretended you already knew the answer and regretted it when the...
141870
Written on 15/12/2012, 21:31 by admin
the-five-ws-of-western-dressageThe “Why?” "The Five W's of Western Dressage": “What? Why? Who? Where? When?” In the last year, there have been lots of people asking, “What is Western Dressage?” You may have seen an article or two labeled, “What is Western Dressage?” Simply put, Western Dressage is a method of training that brings...
Written on 15/10/2012, 18:00 by admin
snaffle-vs-curbI have a question, Randy: If a horse goes nicely in a snaffle, why do you need to change to a curb or (bridle)? Good question, here is the answer: "Very few folks can ride bridlelss, but even fewer can ride with a bridle!" ~ Eitan Beth-Halachmy The simple truth is that you do not need a...
1626670
Written on 14/10/2012, 16:37 by admin
what-did-your-horse-teach-you-today  Question: I have a beautiful 9 year old Paint/Qtr gelding. He hadn't been handled in over a year before we brought him home, but we've been handling him everyday. However, most of the handling has been allowing him to graze on the lead. Last weekend, I attempted to give him some wormer...
152970
Written on 29/09/2012, 15:08 by admin
the-use-of-the-curb-bit-a-lower-levels Bethe Mounce Question---"why the curb chain and not a plain snaffle? This is lower level dressage, right?"This question is in reference to riding Western Dressage tests in a curb bit or snaffle bit. I am not sure if I fully understand the question, but  you mention a curb chain… I think...
Written on 29/09/2012, 15:03 by admin
why-use-a-cavasenRandy I have a question, "why do you use a Cavesson?"thanks Brock HolbrookThat is a great question and here is my answer: Analogy:Think of using a cavesson like you would if you went to the orthodontist to get braces put on your teeth. It is a temporary tool to fix a problem. Once the problem is...
300440
Written on 22/06/2012, 22:40 by admin
randy-byers-truth-revealed"Rearing and flipping over backwards is the single most dangerous thing a horse can do!"Why does a horse rear?Rearing is a refusal to go forward or an evasion to your "go forward" aids or cues!""How do you fix a rearing problem? Simply put, "keep the horse's feet moving in any direction except...
126520
Written on 11/04/2012, 12:29 by admin
what-is-a-bridle-horseDeveloping a good "Western Dressage Bridle Horse" is all about your expectations of what you want in a "finished horse". There are many training methods claiming that they are the only correct way to train a horse. Even though there are many ways to "start", "develop", or "finish" a horse, the...
151960
Written on 04/04/2012, 16:44 by admin
q-a-flying-lead-change"Transitioning from a Simple Change to a Flying Change"   "I am going to be showing this summer, but I have been working for a few months on lead changes and my horse can get where he does like half a trot stride then goes to the next lead, but I can't get him to do an actual flying...
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:13 by admin
ground-manners  "My name is Briana. I’m training a 2-year old mare and she does not know her ground manners. What do I do and how do I teach her good ground manners?"   Thank you for asking these questions. This is a very widely researched topic. There are many books, videos, DVDs and other educational...
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:12 by admin
how-do-i-get-her-to-slow-down  "How do I get her to slow down, collect, and accept the bit and stop being so neurotic about whenever the reins are gathered and the bit makes contact with her mouth?"   This is a great question and you have given me lots of detail to help in forming a response. I like to define a...
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:11 by admin
speed-control  I like to define a ‘broke horse’ by saying that you have full control of direction and impulsion, regardless of how good your ground work is and how soft he is. Using this definition, If you cannot control the speed of the canter, he is not broke or not broke enough. The quick and simple...
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:10 by admin
anthropomorphism “My horse sleeps better at night in a barn because he feels safe, my horse comes to me in the field because he loves me, my horse won't take its medicine just to spite me.” We can’t help but love our equine friends because of their social nature, but can we be accused of the dangerous behavior of...
305190
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:05 by admin
i-can-t-control-my-horse-on-the-ground  Question: I have a beautiful 9 year old Paint/Qtr gelding. He hadn't been handled in over a year before we brought him home, but we've been handling him everyday. However, most of the handling has been allowing him to graze on the lead. Last weekend, I attempted to give him some wormer...
297610
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:01 by admin
active-vs-passive-leadership "In a world full of horse trainers, clinicians and equine professionals competing to make a mark for themselves, many find new ways to reinvent the wheel; however, several try to put their knowledge into some package where we may identify with it all. In the equine world, leadership is the key to...
183000
Written on 26/03/2012, 01:00 by admin
natural-horsemanship-what-is-its-message In the world of “Natural Horsemanship”, there is a widely used phrase “be as soft as possible and as firm as necessary.” It you ask 20 people what Natural Horsemanship means, you will get 20 different answers. There is also a growing concern about how firm is too firm and how gentle is too gentle. If...
Written on 26/03/2012, 00:58 by admin
confidence-is-leadership-in-action-and-fear "I have been raising a family for the last 20 years and I need help with my confidence. I was a fearless rider when I was younger, but now I am nervous. Last year I got hurt and I am not sure if I want to just hop on, now. My horse is very pushy on the ground when I lead him." “Confidence” is...
You are here: Home Home Articles Articles Modern vs Classical Dressage, is there a difference?